The best one to use is the one that does what you want it to.
If you used to be a mod on a forum that has exactly what your looking for then did you think to ask them what they use?
Oh! wait the fog in my crystal ball is clearing and I now know exactly which forum you were a mod on and also exactly which software your on about... if only I had a good memory.
It's not the years honey, it's the mileage...
I do not provide any install services for phpBB, Mods or Styles.
Please do not pm me for support/scripting help - you won't get any reply. If you have a question then make a post in the appropriate forum.